Art inspired by Confederate History Month
Two weekends ago, at RavenCon, one of my artist friends had a piece of artwork on his table in the dealer’s room, in which a skull was overlaid with a Confederate flag graphic. Beneath, it said, “Treason in the defense of slavery should not be celebrated.”
Not too long ago, Governor McDonnell declared April “Confederate History Month” in Virginia (it is already Confederate History Month in several nearby states). Personally, I do not see a problem with this, for reasons I have explained elsewhere.
You might think that I would object to this artwork. You might be surprised.
Art, at its best, should provoke a reaction. Whether it’s lust, or nostalgia, or awe, or some other emotion, the best art affects us. This particular piece of art affects me in two different ways. On the one hand, yes, I absolutely agree with the sentiment behind it. Treason in the defense of slavery should not be celebrated. On the other hand, I strongly disagree that secession was treason, that the Confederates who actually fought in the Civil War were fighting to defend slavery, or that most of the people who would commemorate that conflict are celebrating “treason in the defense of slavery”.
I do not pretend to be an art critic. I can’t even remember the name of my favorite painting, or the artist who painted it (it’s a girl standing on a rock under an open sky, with her dress billowing in the wind — if that rings a bell to you, please drop me a line). But I think this is an effective piece of artwork, on par with (and in my opinion superior to) Shepard Fairey’s “Hope” poster. This challenges us, and does so with a clean and immediately understandable design.
Well done, Andy.
Share
Blackmoor Vituperative


