[x]Blackmoor Vituperative

Friday, 2006-04-28

Are anti-DRM declarations falling on deaf ears?

Filed under: Intellectual Property — bblackmoor @ 11:25

Just say no to iPodDavid Berlind has an article on CNet called “Are anti-DRM declarations falling on deaf ears?“. (The answer to that question, of course, is “yes”.)

The primary targets for his ire are Apple and their malevolent “Fairplay” restrictions on music purchased through iTunes, but the problem goes deeper than that. The media robber barons are colluding with electronics manufacturers and legislators to impose their malicious restrictions on everything that you buy. This is no different from the opposition to the printing press in the 15th century, and the consequences, should the media robber barons be successful, will be no less dire than if the the Eurpean nobility and the papal court had succeeded in supressing the movable type printing press.

This isn’t just about music, or software — this is about the future of our civilization.

Are you listening?

Wednesday, 2006-04-19

Streamcast to slug it out in court with RIAA, MPAA

Filed under: Intellectual Property — bblackmoor @ 21:29

This news is a week old, but I just heard about it, so maybe you haven’t heard about it, either.

As part of their strategy to crack down on users of P2P file-sharing software, the RIAA and MPAA also went after the makers of the file-sharing apps. They saw their greatest success in the MGM v. Grokster case, in which the Supreme Court of the United States ruled that Grokster could be held liable for the copyright-infringing use of its software and network and sent the case back to a lower court.

Streamcast Networks, which is responsible for the file-sharing program Morpheus, has decided to take its chances in court, breaking off settlement negotiations with record labels and movie studios. The RIAA and MPAA had informed Streamcast along with seven other companies of their intent to file suit against them in the wake of the MGM v. Grokster ruling last summer.

Streamcast’s decision to fight it out in court marks a change of heart for the company, which prevously said it planned to settle the case. In a statement, Streamcast CEO Michael Weiss noted his disappointment that the company couldn’t come to an agreement with the labels and studios and said that Streamcast wants its “day in court.”

One aspect of the negotiations between Streamcast and the plaintiffs had revolved around legitimizing the P2P service, perhaps in a fashion similar to iMesh. However, Weiss said that the negotiations soured when the talks turned from “a full-on partnership into a one-sided, unworkable deal.”

(from ArsTechinca, Streamcast to slug it out in court with RIAA, MPAA)

Just so we are all clear, here: organizations like MPAA, Macrovision, and RIAA are evil. They subvert the legal system and cripple the ability of future generations to create and enjoy works of art in every field: novelists, painters, filmmakers, musicians, singers, and everyone who enjoys these works are all being disenfranchised for decades, if not centuries, because of these ruthless gangsters.

Monday, 2006-04-10

Superboy in court

Filed under: Entertainment,Intellectual Property — bblackmoor @ 11:21

The Legion Omnicom has a really great description of the legal tussle over Superboy, with lots of links and really tight commentary by knowledgable people. So go read that: I won’t waste your time by trying to summarize it here (any more than I just did, anyway).

Of course, if Disney hadn’t kept bribing lobbying Congress into extending copyright protection ad infinitum, this whole thing would be a non-issue. (Because it would be a trademark issue instead, and trademarks never expire. Yeah, that’s a mess, too….)

Tuesday, 2006-04-04

Intellectual property run amok

Filed under: Intellectual Property — bblackmoor @ 19:48

Mother Jones has an amusing compilation of “intellectual property” stupidity.

Between Lawyers has an amusing exchange about it.

It’s good to know that IP lawyers can get a chuckle while destroying our future.

Wednesday, 2006-03-29

Black Mask

Filed under: Gaming,Intellectual Property — bblackmoor @ 23:55

Black MaskNo, not the Jet Li movie.

I’m not an artist, but I like to draw. I spent the last couple of weeks working on this drawing of “Black Mask“, the WestGuard cruiser. I drew it in Inkscape, a great free (open source) SVG drawing program.

Like all of the gaming material I create these days, the image and the original file are released under the Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike license. If you create gaming material, you should seriously consider releasing it all under this license.

Wednesday, 2006-03-15

GPL poses no special Sarbanes-Oxley risk

Filed under: Intellectual Property,Linux — bblackmoor @ 00:22

This isn’t exactly a scoop, but hey, I’ve been busy.

Some have recently argued that corporate executives face increased risk of criminal liability under the Sarbanes-Oxley Act of 2002 (SOX) if their companies develop and distribute code licensed under the GNU General Public License (GPL). The argument, as it has been made, raises significant concerns about SOX compliance, but it fails to clarify the scope and context of these points. We have reviewed these issues and, as discussed more fully below, there is in fact no special risk for developing GPL’d code under SOX. Under most circumstances, the risk posed to a company by SOX is not affected by whether they use GPL’d or any other type of software. Arguments to the contrary are pure anti-GPL FUD.

(from Software Freedom Law Center, Sarbanes-Oxley and the GPL: No Special Risk)

I’m not sure what Wasabi thought they were accomplishing by publishing their scare-tactics white paper, but anyone familiar with SarbOx and familiar with the terms of the GPL (and really, it isn’t hard to be one of those people, all it takes is some time to read up on them) can see that they’re blowing smoke. Shame on them.

Tuesday, 2006-01-17

GPL 3.0 draft tackles patents, compatibility

Filed under: Intellectual Property,Linux — bblackmoor @ 14:51

The first discussion draft of the GNU General Public License was finally released on Monday, and addresses the issues of patents and patent-related retaliation, as well as its compatibility with other licenses.

Richard Stallman, the founder of the Free Software Foundation and author of the original license, was the first to take the floor here at the First International Conference on GPLv3 at MIT (the Massachusetts Institute of Technology), to express his vision for the new license. […]

The biggest changes to the license were in the area of license compatibility, removing the obstacles that prevented it from being combined with code from other free software packages. […]

The other biggest changes to the license were regarding the issue of DRM (Digital Rights Management), which was seen as denying users the freedom to control the software they had.

“DRM is a malicious feature and can never be tolerated, as DRM is fundamentally based on activities that cannot be done with free software. That is its goal and it is in direct opposition to ours. But, with the new GPL, we can now prevent our software from being perverted or corrupted,” he said.

A patent license grant has now also been included, as well as a narrow kind of patent retaliation clause. “If person A makes a modified version of a GPL-covered program and then gets a patent on that and says if anyone else makes such a modified version, they will be sued, he then loses the right to make any modifications, meaning he can’t commercially use his software,” Stallman said.

While the license does not require that the modified version be released, it does ensure that others would not be prevented from writing similar modifications under the license, he said.

(from eWeek, GPL 3.0 Draft Tackles Patents, Compatibility)

These sound like good changes to me. If you want more detail (and you should), you can read the full text of the GPL 3.0. You may also want to check out the Free Software Foundation’s rationale for the changes in GPL 3.0.

Tuesday, 2005-12-06

Sony gets sued

Filed under: Intellectual Property,Music — bblackmoor @ 18:12

From the moment I learned about the illegal hacking of customers’ computers by Sony, I have been calling and writing my legislators to urge them to initiate legal action against the company.

Well, it looks like the ball has started rolling.

According to eWeek, Sony’s legal problems have begun, and hopefully they will continue for quite a while.

“The allegation that Sony has incorporated open-source software into its purportedly proprietary software in a manner inconsistent with the Open Source General Public License, if established, would create a nice irony,” said Simon J. Frankel, an IP (intellectual property) attorney and partner with Howard Rice Nemerovski Canady Falk & Rabkin LLP in San Francisco.

“The entire purpose of open-source software is to make broadly useful software available for all to build on. For Sony to take such software and incorporate it into software that it claims as proprietary would be contrary to the entire spirit of open source,” Frankel said.

“The improper use of GPL software by Sony could be the basis of a claim for violation of the GPL, which could prevent Sony from utilizing the rootkit program to the extent that it includes GPL software and, if a proper party were definable, could even subject Sony to damages claims under the license and copyright principles,” said Michael R. Graham, IP attorney and partner with Marshall, Gerstein & Borun LLP, a Chicago-based law firm specializing in IP.

Not long after that, the lawsuits bagan. The first suit came from the EFF (Electronic Freedom Foundation), but it was soon followed by a suit from the state of Texas.

“On a very basic level of product liability law, if Sony is distributing a product that causes damage to consumers, then it may well be held liable,” Frankel said.

“There also appears to be a particular Texas statute that may make Sony liable for distributing spyware to consumers’ computers. This potential legal liability only piles on to the tremendous public relations snafu caused by Sony’s media player,” Frankel added.

(from eWeek, Sony’s Rootkit DRM Raises Legal Red Flags)

Way to go, Texas! Time for Virginia to step up to the plate.

Indeed, one way or another, thanks to its use and licensing of XCP DRM, Sony may be in for quite a legal shipwreck.

By all the gods of music and video, let’s hope so.

Monday, 2005-11-14

DHS criticizes Sony’s illegal tactics

Filed under: Intellectual Property,Music — bblackmoor @ 10:03

In response to the illegal hacking of customers’ computers by Sony, Stewart Baker, recently appointed by President Bush as the Department Of Homeland Security’s assistant secretary for policy, made a comment aimed directly at Sony and others who would illegally hack into their customers’ computers in the name of protecting their “intellectual property”:

In a remark clearly aimed directly at Sony and other labels, Stewart continued: “It’s very important to remember that it’s your intellectual property — it’s not your computer. And in the pursuit of protection of intellectual property, it’s important not to defeat or undermine the security measures that people need to adopt in these days.”

(from The Washington Post, DHS Official Weighs In on Sony)

What I want to know is where are the criminal charges? Why aren’t these people being arrested? This was a premeditated, wide-scale hacking attempt on a huge number of computers — I want to see people put in handcuffs and taken away to pay for their crime. I want to see large men with shaved heads do to Sony executives what Sony has been attempting to do to us.

Friday, 2005-11-04

Sony illegally hacks customers’ PCs

Filed under: Intellectual Property,Music — bblackmoor @ 11:02

I’ve been saying that things will get worse before they get better. They just got worse.

On Monday, October 31, alert users discovered that Sony BMG is using copy-protected CDs to surreptitiously install its digital rights management technology onto PCs. You don’t have to be ripping the CD, either–just playing it from your CD-ROM drive triggers the installation. The software installs itself as a root kit, which is a set of tools commonly used to make certain files and processes undetectable, and they’re the favored tool of crackers who are, as Wikipedia puts it, attempting to “maintain access to a system for malicious purposes.” In fact, root kits are often classified alongside Trojan horses. And Mark Russinovich, who created a root-kit detection utility and was one of the first to blog about the Sony intrusion, discovered another little gem when he tried to remove the DRM drivers. It broke his computer — disabling his CD drive.

(from CNet, DRM this, Sony!)

Folks, this is illegal (and I’m reporting it to the FBI). But will anyone at Sony be prosecuted for this crime? Don’t hold your breath.

Here’s a tip from me to Sony, RIAA, and the rest of the media robber barons: if you want to compete with services like AllOfMP3.com, do what they do, do it better, and do it cheaper. If you continue to pin your hopes on DRM, you will fail, you will be reviled, and your stockholders will suffer.

« Previous Page — Next Page »