EU rejects software patents
Finally, some good news:
The European Parliament overwhelmingly rejects the proposed IT patenting directive — and the European Commission will not issue another proposal.
(from eWeek.com)
Finally, some good news:
The European Parliament overwhelmingly rejects the proposed IT patenting directive — and the European Commission will not issue another proposal.
(from eWeek.com)
The US Supreme Court Monday handed the entertainment industry a major win in its ongoing battle to destroy the public domain and control all information everywhere.
In the MGM vs. Grokster case, judges voted unanimously that software companies may be sued when consumers use the service to share music and movies, overturning an earlier ruling that sheltered peer-to-peer services from frivolous lawsuits from the multi-billion-dollar entertainment industry.
Thanks to the Stepford Court and media brigands like MGM, you can’t create a device or technology that can be used in a way which will open the door to frivolous lawsuits, or you will become a target yourself. Thanks to Disney and the idiots in Congress, nothing ever written down, drawn, filmed, or recorded will ever enter the public domain again. Thanks to the software robber barons like Apple and Microsoft, even obvious applications of prior art will be licensed and controlled. Creativity will vanish, and gradually every form of expression will either be forbidden or will involve extortion money paid to the media brigands.
Make no mistake: this is the end of the world. It will get worse before it gets better.
Now here’s someone who gets it. ZDNet’s Dana Blankenhorn skewers the nonsense being spouted by Sun’s president Jonathan Schwartz, and calls it what it is: a self-serving attempt to profit indefinitely from work done in the past, and to profit from the work of others in the future. If people like Schwartz had their way, we’d all be pushing ploughs and tithing to the local warlord.
Dan Farber at ZDNet has an tepid piece on Lawrence Lessig‘s speech at the Open Source Business Conference. I wish we could have access to the full text of Lessig’s speech. Instead, Farber provides us with sound bites:
“There is a war against the freedom to innovate and this community has done way too little to resist,” Lessig said. “I am a puny, independent law professor. If you are depending on me [to fight the war] you are hopeless and lost,” he added.
A good summary, but I would have liked to read the meat of Lessig’s speech. I could also do without Farber’s facile acceptance of the tragic state of intellectual property law and the one-sided propaganda from RIAA, MPAA, and their ilk:
The battle isn’t strictly about open source versus closed source software or whether piracy is an evil. That’s a given.
No, Dan: it’s not a given. It’s not a given because defining the vast majority of “unauthorized copying” as “piracy” is a fiction invented to demonize fair use so that large media companies can further pervert our legal system to line their own pockets.
It’s a shame that the main theme of Lessig’s speech went over Farber’s head:
“More significant is to become part of the debate. The biggest problem is that the debate is dominated by lawyers and lobbyists who don’t have a direct stake in the outcome.”
He’s talking about you, Dan. Take your head out of the sand and stop parroting the propaganda from the real pirates: RIAA, MPAA, and the other robber barons of the digital age.
Here’s another case of a company (ab)using the legal system to make the world a less creative place. That is no surprise, but this is: this time, the evil corporation is Apple. An employee at Google created a Mac OSX inspired interface, where the icons enlarged when the cursor rolled over them, complete with a little love poem to OSX. Ah, the pain of unrequited love: Apple appears to have objected (Apple has sought patent protection for its rollover technique), and the offending page is now missing from Google (however, you can see a mirror of it here).
A patent for a rollover? Are they kidding? No, sadly: they aren’t.
Mark my words: if we don’t reverse this trend of permitting companies to subvert the legal system for their personal (or corporate) gain, it is going to be the downfall of our society. That isn’t hyperbole, folks.
I have learned that there is a grassroots campaign asking for movie studios and DVD manufacturers to get their act together before dumping a pile of mutually incompatible high definition DVD (HD-DVD) formats on the market. I have mixed feelings about this.
On the one hand, I wholeheartedly support any effort to get manufacturers to pull their heads out of their collective ass. The nonsense with DVD-R, DVD+R, ad nauseam is ridiculous: there was and is no need for the introduction 0f DVD+R or DVD+RW. DVD-R, DVD-RW, and DVD-RAM are the official standards, and they are completely adequate to the tasks they perform.
On the other hand, I do support technological diversity, because I think it permits consumers to participate in the weeding-out process. Would you rather have used Betamax videotapes during the 1990s, with their two-hour limit on tape length? I wouldn’t. I am also leery of the ongoing war that large media companies are waging against fair use — a war they are waging against you and me, using the courts, technology, propaganda, bullying, and any other tactic that they can get away with. If they are permitted to dictate the next DVD format, you can be sure that it will be so encumbered by “digital rights management” features that it will make the current “region code” nonsense seem a utopian dream by comparison. In fact, I wouldn’t be surprised if they eventually tried shackling each DVD to a specific player, and then charge you a fee every time you push “Play”. There’s simply no lower or more debased creature than a control freak.
So: do I want there to be a single, robust, universal HD-DVD standard? Yes. Do I trust the studios and large media companies to create it? Absolutely not. I want competing standards. I don’t want to see the next DivX become a success because it has no competition.
In this lovely item from The Register, we see that the cancer called intellectual property is claiming more victims:
In the first case of its kind, a California video game maker is suing an entire community of software tinkerers for reverse engineering and modifying Xbox games that they legally purchased….
The lawsuit claims the ninjahacker.net users decompiled the code to several Tecmo titles, including Ninja Gaiden, Dead or Alive 3, and Dead or Alive Xtreme Beach Volleyball, and figured out how to create their own “skins” that change the appearance of game characters. They swapped modding techniques and hundreds of custom skins over the website message board.
The defendants are not accused of pirating the games, and the modifications and methods at issue appear no different than those employed by hobbyists on other video games — from Halo to the Sims 2 — for years. But according to the lawsuit, Tecmo suffers in the practice anyway…. (The Register, http://www.theregister.co.uk/2005/02/10/tecmo_sues_xbox_game_hackers/)
So, from Tecmo’s point of view, even though you paid for the game, you can only play it in the manner the publisher intended. This should come as no surprise. The robber barons at MPAA and RIAA — the real pirates — have been making this argument in the courts for years: successfully, in most cases. It won’t change anything, of course — the genie is out of the bottle, and getting further away from the robber barons’ grasp all the time. With books like Steal This File Sharing Book on the shelves, and the ceaseless motivation of ingenious human beings, it’s only a mater of time. As the author of Steal This File Sharing Book says:
The bottom line is that the corporations, who currently hold all the power and make most of the money, are going to have to change, and that’s something they aren’t willing to do…. Unfortunately for them, their fate is already sealed and out of their hands in the same way that buggy whip manufacturers, slide rule makers, and whale-oil lamp companies found themselves wiped out by technological change.
The question isn’t whether file sharing technology will put today’s corporate powerhouses out of business. The question is when, and that future is closer than they think. (Wallace Wang, Steal This File Sharing Book, 2004)
Another question is how much damage the robber barons can do to the rest of us in the meantime. The answer to that is, “As much as they can get away with.”
It’s no secret that I think that intellectual property law in the USA is broken. Here’s another example, from Red Hat’s Fedora Trademark Guidelines:
Fedoraâ„¢ is a trademark of Red Hat, Inc. and may only be used with Red Hat Inc.’s express permission. Except as provided herein, you may not use “Fedora” or any confusingly similar mark as a trademark for your product, or use “Fedora” in any other manner that might cause confusion in the marketplace, including in advertising, on auction sites, or on software or hardware. Any party wishing to use the Fedoraâ„¢ mark may do so as long as they meet two conditions:
- They must only use the Fedoraâ„¢ mark in association with the original Fedoraâ„¢ code found on the Fedora Project website (see http://fedora.redhat.com/) without modification; and
- If they charge a fee for the CD-ROM or other media on which they deliver the Fedoraâ„¢ code, they warranty the media on which the Fedoraâ„¢ code is delivered, thus ensuring that the recipient receives a usable copy.
This same permission applies to such other Red Hat trademarks as are included in the authorized Fedoraâ„¢ distribution, such as RPMâ„¢. Except as expressly stated herein, no other rights are granted to use any other Red Hat trademarks, specifically including the RED HAT® and “Shadowman” logo® marks. Absolutely no exceptions.
There’s only one problem with this: Red hat does not own this trademark. The Fedora Project at University Of Virginia and Cornell University has owned this trademark since 1998:
Fedora is a general purpose repository service developed jointly by The University of Virginia Library and Cornell University. The Fedora project is devoted to the goal of providing open-source repository software that can serve as the foundation for many types of information management systems.
The software demonstrates how distributed digital information management can be deployed using web-based technologies, including XML and web services.
According to the Fedora Project web site:
The Cornell and Virginia teams have taken a number of steps to try to work with Red Hat regarding use of the name Fedora™. At this date, Red Hat has refused our request to withdraw its trademark applications and reverse its claims of usage restrictions on the name. Cornell University and the University of Virginia are now considering various legal options in response to Red Hat’s actions.
Referring back to the Red Hat Fedora web site, I found an email address for trademark isues: trademarks@redhat.com. Unfortunately, mail sent to that address bounces, with the following message:
This email address has been deactivated. Email sent to this address IS
NOT RECEIVED by a person at Red Hat….
At this point, the smell of rat becomes unmistakable.
I happen to like Red Hat, and Red Hat Fedora. I run Red Hat Fedora on my server at home, and on the development machine at work. I have no grudge against Red Hat. But what they are doing here is wrong, and they appear to know that it’s wrong.
I am reminded of the arguments used by those who support Drug Prohibition: that certain chemicals are dangerous, not necessarily in themselves, but because they incite the people taking them to commit criminal acts. IP law in the USA has become so toxic, so perverse, that it corrupts those who come into contact with it. Red Hat is not the criminal here — Red Hat is a victim. That does not absolve them of guilt, but it does mean that they need more than to be punished and to make restitution: they need counseling, and they need to break free of the toxic addiction that has driven them to commit such despicable acts.
And we, as a society, need to do something about the cause of this cancer eating away at our creative and commercial future. A good start, if you are interested in that sort of thing, is to read Lawrence Lessig’s blog.
My personal opinion is that the entire structure of intellectiual property law in the USA and much of the world is so grievously broken that it will soon be either scrapped or ignored by the average person. We are all aware of how ridiculous patent law has become. Trademarks and copyrights are not far behind. You have probably heard about “Happy Birthday”, for example:
The Chicago-based music publisher Clayton F. Summy Company, working with Jessica Hill, published and copyrighted “Happy Birthday” in 1935. Under the laws in effect at the time, the Hills’ copyright would have expired after one 28-year term and a renewal of similar length, falling into public domain by 1991. However, the Copyright Act of 1976 extended the term of copyright protection to 75 years from date of publication, and the Copyright Term Extension Act of 1998 added another 20 years, so under current law the copyright protection of “Happy Birthday” will remain intact until at least 2030. (Urban Legends Reference Pages, http://www.snopes.com/music/songs/birthday.htm)
I would be willing to bet a sizeable sum that “Happy Birthday” never becomes public domain. Does that seem right to you?
The big news at the LinuxWorld conference is that OSI is planning to trim the ridiculous number of OSI-approved open source licenses down from 50 or so to around 3. Personally, I think that’s a good thing.
There is a natural impulse to create a new thing even when there is no need for one. I think that’s what is at the root of this current situation. I’m certainly not immune: once upon a time, I was one of the people who wrote the October Open Gaming License, or OOGL, which was supposed to be to role-playing games what the Apache license was to software. You’ve probably never heard of it, and for good reason. There were already other open licenses which were completely adequate for gaming. Why invent another one? The OOGL never caught on (it was actually used only once, as far as I know, in a game called Four Colors Al Fresco), and eventually we (the people who wrote it) realized that it just wasn’t worth the effort to keep track of yet another license. We stopped using the OOGL in 2002 (switching to the exceedingly cool Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike license), Woodelf (the author of Four Colors Al Fresco) did the same, and eventually we took the OOGL offline entirely.
Most other open source licenses should do the same. There’s no need to reinvent the wheel, even if it is pretty cool to say, “hey look at this wheel: I made it myself”. So I agree with OSI on this one.
(Incidentally, any mention you see of the OOGL which makes it sound like that license is still in use is either woefully out of date or the work of some net loon with an axe to grind. Feel free to correct them, if you’ve some free time.)